Asphalt vs. Metal Roofs: Which is Best for Your Pennsylvania Home?
Compare materials, budget, and climate performance for your next exterior investment.
Written by Mike Banes
Owner of ELR Roofing
Pennsylvania weather demands a lot from your home’s exterior. Between freezing winter ice storms in the Perkiomen Valley and intense summer humidity, choosing the right roofing material is the most critical decision in your replacement project.
For most homeowners in Montgomery County, the decision comes down to the two industry leaders: modern architectural asphalt shingles and standing seam metal roofing. Here is a complete breakdown of how they compare, how they handle the local climate, and which one is the right investment for your home.
Architectural Asphalt Shingles: The Reliable Standard
Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material in North America, and for good reason. They offer an exceptional balance of affordability, versatility, and proven protection.
It is important to note that modern architectural shingles are vastly superior to the flat, 3-tab shingles of the past. Built with multiple layers of fiberglass and asphalt, they create a dimensional look that mimics wood shake while offering heavy-duty weather resistance.
- Wind Resistance: Premium architectural shingles are engineered to withstand severe weather, offering wind warranties up to 130 mph—more than enough to handle harsh Pennsylvania summer thunderstorms.
- Aesthetic Versatility: Available in dozens of color palettes, from classic warm tones to bold designer blends, making it easy to match your home’s unique curb appeal.
- Cost-Effective: Asphalt provides the lowest barrier to entry for a full roof replacement, offering excellent value for a 20 to 30-year lifespan.
- The Drawback: Asphalt absorbs heat during the summer and is more susceptible to the friction of ice and snow compared to smoother materials.
Metal Roofing Systems: The “Lifetime” Upgrade
If you are looking for a “one-and-done” roofing solution, metal is the ultimate upgrade. At ELR Roofing, we install the two most popular styles of metal roofing for residential homes, each offering incredible durability and energy efficiency:
- Standing Seam Metal (Hidden Fastener): The premium choice. These roofs feature interlocking panels with hidden fasteners, creating a sleek, modern, and impenetrable barrier that can easily last 50+ years with virtually no maintenance.
- Corrugated Metal (Exposed Fastener): Highly popular for the “modern farmhouse” aesthetic. This is a more cost-effective way to get the longevity of a metal roof, though it does require slightly more maintenance over the decades to ensure the exposed rubber-grommet screws remain watertight.
- Winter Weather Performance: Both styles of metal roofs excel in PA winters. Their smooth surfaces allow heavy snow to slide right off, drastically reducing the risk of ice dams building up along your eaves.
- Summer Cooling: Instead of absorbing the summer sun like asphalt, metal reflects UV rays, which can help keep your attic cooler and lower your seasonal HVAC costs.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Swipe left to compare options →
| Feature | Architectural Asphalt | Standing Seam Metal |
|---|---|---|
| Average PA Lifespan | 20–30 Years | 40–70+ Years |
| Initial Investment | $ (Most Affordable) | $$$ (Premium) |
| Snow & Ice Performance | Good (Requires quality ice/water shield) | Excellent (Snow slides off naturally) |
| Wind Resistance | Up to 130 mph | 140+ mph |
| Maintenance | Moderate (Check for granule loss, moss) | Very Low |
Trusted Industry Resources
Owens Corning Shingles
Explore durable architectural asphalt shinglesor test colors on your home using our Owens Corning Roof Color Visualizer.
Manufacturer Warranties
As an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, ELR Roofing can offer exclusive System Protection Warranties that standard roofers cannot provide.
ENERGY STAR® & Cool Roofs
Discover how Owens Corning’s solar-reflecting shingles meet strict ENERGY STAR® standards to lower your summer cooling costs.
A Note on Flat Roofs: Low-Slope Membranes
If your home has a flat addition, a low-pitch porch, or a garage, neither asphalt nor metal is the right choice. Water moves too slowly off flat surfaces, which will cause standard shingles to leak.
For these specific areas, we utilize Low-Slope Membranes, specifically specialized TPO (Thermoplastic Polyolefin) or EPDM (rubber) systems. These materials are heat-welded or chemically adhered to create a single, monolithic, leak-proof barrier specifically designed to handle pooling water.
Choosing the right material ultimately comes down to your budget, your aesthetic preferences, and how long you plan to stay in your home. At ELR Roofing, we never push you toward a product you don’t need. Our goal is to provide you with the facts, transparent pricing, and a flawless installation backed by our 5-year workmanship guarantee.Want to learn more about protecting your investment? Return to our Roofing Learning Center for more homeowner guides.
If you are ready to explore material samples or want a professional assessment of your current roof, reach out to me directly at (267) 718-4790 or request a free estimate to start the conversation.
Why Homeowners Choose ELR Roofing
Unlike larger regional companies that send a salesman to write an estimate and then subcontract your roof to an unfamiliar crew, ELR Roofing does things differently. When you hire ELR, you deal directly with me, Mike Banes. I am on site for every single project to oversee quality, ensure clear communication, and make sure your property is treated with complete respect from start to finish.
